Skip to content

Can You Crate a Puppy and an Older Dog Together? | Dog Safety

It is generally not recommended to crate a puppy and an older dog together. Puppies have different needs, including more frequent bathroom breaks and higher energy levels, which may disturb an older dog. Additionally, confining them together in a small space could lead to conflicts, especially if they have different temperaments or feeding schedules. Each dog should have its own space to feel safe and comfortable. If you’re introducing a puppy to an older dog, it’s best to crate them separately to ensure both pets are comfortable and avoid potential stress or injury.

Crate training is a widely recommended method for managing a dog’s behavior, providing a safe space, and aiding in potty training. But what happens when you have a puppy and an older dog? Can you crate them together for convenience or comfort? While it might seem like a practical solution, crating a puppy and an older dog together comes with some significant challenges and potential risks.

In this blog post, we’ll explore the pros and cons of crating dogs together, why separate crates are often the best choice, and provide alternative strategies for peacefully coexisting with both a puppy and an older dog.

The Purpose of Crate Training

Before diving into whether you can crate a puppy and an older dog together, it’s important to understand the role of crate training for each dog. Crates serve as a safe, secure environment where dogs can rest, feel comfortable, and avoid destructive behaviors, especially when unsupervised. Here’s how it benefits both puppies and older dogs:

  • For puppies: Crates help with potty training, teaching them bladder control by confining them to a small space when they’re not being supervised. They also help reduce anxiety, especially when adjusting to a new home.
  • For older dogs: Crates offer a quiet retreat where they can relax without disturbance, especially in a household with younger, more energetic dogs. Crates can also help prevent unwanted behaviors like chewing or getting into things.

Since puppies and older dogs have different needs and behaviors, crating them together introduces a range of issues that can impact both dogs’ well-being.

Can You Crate a Puppy and an Older Dog Together?

The short answer is no, it’s generally not recommended to crate a puppy and an older dog together. Although the idea might seem cozy or convenient, the risks and challenges outweigh any potential benefits. Here’s why:

1. Different Developmental Needs

Puppies and older dogs are at vastly different stages of development. Puppies are full of energy, highly curious, and still learning essential behaviors like potty training, chewing control, and basic manners. Older dogs, on the other hand, often value routine, calmness, and personal space, especially if they’ve already settled into a more relaxed lifestyle.

  • Puppy energy: Puppies are notorious for being energetic, playful, and sometimes disruptive. They may want to chew, jump, or climb on the older dog inside the crate. This can quickly irritate or stress out the older dog, who likely prefers peace and quiet.
  • Different schedules: Puppies need to go out frequently for potty breaks (usually every 1-2 hours), while an older, fully trained dog can hold their bladder for much longer periods. Sharing a crate could lead to accidents, confusion, or frustration for both dogs.

2. Space and Safety Concerns

Crates are designed to give a dog enough room to turn around, lie down, and stand up comfortably. When you place two dogs in the same crate, space becomes an issue. Overcrowding can cause discomfort, and if the dogs feel cramped, it can lead to stress or aggression.

  • Risk of injury: Puppies are still learning boundaries and control. A boisterous puppy might inadvertently hurt the older dog by stepping on them or playfully nipping. Similarly, an older dog who becomes irritated by the puppy might respond by growling, snapping, or even biting in the confined space of a crate.
  • Different sizes: If the dogs are different in size, there is a risk of the puppy being squashed or hurt if the older dog rolls over or shifts in their sleep. Puppies, in particular, are fragile and need to be handled carefully in confined spaces.

3. Behavioral Differences

Puppies are learning the ropes when it comes to crate training and appropriate behavior, while older dogs (if already trained) are used to following routines. Crating them together can disrupt those routines and potentially cause behavioral regressions.

  • Chewing and destruction: Puppies are notorious chewers. If a puppy starts chewing on the crate or even the older dog’s bed or toys, it could stress out the older dog or lead to tension.
  • Territorial disputes: Crates are meant to be personal spaces. For an older dog who is used to having their own space, sharing it with a rambunctious puppy can create feelings of insecurity or lead to territorial disputes.

4. Health and Rest Concerns

Puppies require a lot of rest and undisturbed sleep, but they also have more erratic sleep patterns compared to older dogs. While a puppy may wake up frequently to explore or relieve themselves, an older dog might need continuous, uninterrupted sleep for health reasons.

  • Rest disruption: Puppies may disturb an older dog’s sleep or even wake them up repeatedly by pawing, barking, or moving around in the crate. This can lead to crankiness, stress, and overall discomfort for the older dog, especially if they have arthritis or joint pain.
  • Health risks: If the older dog has health issues or is recovering from surgery, sharing a crate with a hyperactive puppy could pose risks. Puppies often don’t understand when to leave a dog alone, which could lead to unnecessary strain or injury for the older dog.

Why Separate Crates Are Better

Instead of crating your puppy and older dog together, it’s highly recommended to provide separate crates for each dog. Here’s why separate crates work better:

1. Personal Space

Both dogs can enjoy their own space, which helps them feel secure and comfortable. The older dog won’t feel overwhelmed by the puppy’s energy, and the puppy will have room to explore their space safely without risking injury.

  • Comfort zones: By having their own crates, each dog can rest and relax in an environment tailored to their needs. You can provide extra padding for the older dog’s crate if they have joint issues, while the puppy’s crate can include chew toys to help with teething.

2. Tailored Routines

Puppies and older dogs have different routines. With separate crates, you can control their schedules more effectively. The puppy will need more frequent bathroom breaks and might spend less time crated during the day as they get used to crate training.

  • Avoid accidents: By crating them separately, you avoid the possibility of the puppy having an accident inside the crate and disturbing the older dog. This helps keep both crates clean and your potty training efforts on track.

3. Safer and Less Stressful

With individual crates, you minimize the risk of injury and stress. The older dog can retreat to their own space to rest without being pestered, while the puppy can have their own crate to explore, chew, and learn crate training at their own pace.

  • Better sleep for both: The puppy’s more erratic sleep and activity schedule won’t affect the older dog’s sleep needs, ensuring that both dogs are well-rested and less irritable.

4. Training Benefits

Crating separately also helps with individual training. Puppies can learn to love their crate as their own personal space, which can help with potty training, chewing control, and overall behavior. Older dogs will appreciate having their routine undisturbed, and they won’t regress in their training or habits.

How to Introduce Crates to Both Dogs

If you decide to use separate crates, it’s important to introduce the concept to both dogs in a way that encourages them to see their crates as positive spaces. Here’s how you can do that:

1. Choose the Right Crate Size

Make sure each dog has a crate that is the appropriate size for them. The crate should be big enough for the dog to stand, turn around, and lie down comfortably but not so large that the puppy has room to potty in one corner and sleep in another.

2. Make It Cozy

Add soft bedding, a few toys, and perhaps even an old T-shirt that smells like you to each crate. This will make it feel like a cozy den for the dogs and help them feel more secure in their space.

3. Positive Reinforcement

Use treats and praise when introducing your dogs to their crates. Encourage them to go inside the crate on their own, and never use the crate as a form of punishment.

4. Gradual Introductions

For a puppy that is new to crate training, introduce the crate in short intervals. Let the puppy spend just a few minutes inside, gradually increasing the time as they become more comfortable. Meanwhile, reinforce the older dog’s positive association with the crate by providing them with their favorite treat or toy when they go inside.

5. Crate Placement

Place the crates in a location where both dogs can feel part of the family but still have their own space. Many dog owners place crates in a bedroom or living area where the dogs can still see people but remain secure in their own space.

Alternatives to Crating Together

If your dogs seem to seek each other’s company and you’re looking for ways to keep them close, here are a few alternatives to crating them together:

  • Side-by-side crates: Place the crates next to each other so that both dogs can feel close but still have their individual space. This way, they can see and smell each other but won’t interfere with each other’s rest.
  • Exercise pens: For more freedom, you can set up an exercise pen that gives both dogs enough space to move around but still confines them to a safe area. Make sure each dog has their own bed and toys within the pen.
  • Supervised together time: Allow your dogs to spend supervised time together outside of the crate, but ensure that each dog has a personal space they can retreat to when they need rest or want to be alone. Supervised time together helps build their bond, but having separate spaces prevents any tension or conflict.
  • What to Do If Your Puppy or Older Dog Is Resistant to Crate Training
  • Crate training can be more challenging for some dogs, whether they’re a young puppy or a senior dog. Here are a few tips to help with the transition if either dog seems hesitant about their crate:
  • 1. Start Slow
  • If your puppy or older dog is nervous about the crate, start by leaving the door open and allowing them to explore the crate on their own terms. Use treats or toys to lure them inside, but never force them into the crate, as this can create a negative association.
  • 2. Feed Meals Inside the Crate
  • One effective way to get your dog used to the crate is by feeding them inside it. This makes the crate a positive place linked with something enjoyable, like eating. Over time, the dog will become more comfortable entering the crate willingly.
  • 3. Cover the Crate
  • Some dogs feel more secure when their crate is covered, creating a dark, den-like space. You can drape a blanket or towel over part of the crate (but make sure there’s still proper ventilation). This can help both dogs feel more secure, especially if they are nervous in new environments.
  • 4. Don’t Use the Crate as Punishment
  • Always ensure the crate is a positive and safe space. Never send your puppy or older dog to the crate as a form of punishment. This can make them fear or resent the crate, which will make training much harder and cause unnecessary stress.
  • Final Thoughts: Should You Crate a Puppy and an Older Dog Together?
  • While it might be tempting to crate a puppy and an older dog together for convenience or comfort, it’s generally not a good idea. Puppies and older dogs have different needs, from energy levels to potty schedules, and crating them together can create safety risks, cause stress, and even lead to conflict between the two.
  • By providing separate crates for each dog, you’re giving them their own space where they can feel safe, secure, and relaxed. This allows you to tailor each dog’s crate environment and training routine to their individual needs, ensuring that both your puppy and older dog thrive.
  • Remember, crate training takes time and patience, but with the right approach, your dogs will come to see their crates as positive spaces where they can rest and recharge. Always prioritize their comfort and safety, and you’ll soon have two happy, well-behaved dogs who love their personal spaces.